Document Type : Original Article
Authors
- Ardeshir Mazkouri 1
- Gholamreza Memarzadeh Tehran 2
- Morteza Mousakhani 3
- Zahra Moghimi 4
- Yadollah Saboohi 5
1 PhD Student Faculty of Management and Economics, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Ira
2 Associate Professor, Department of Public Administration, Faculty of Management and Economics, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
3 Professor, Department of Public Administration, Faculty of Management and Economics, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
4 Assistant Professor, Department of Public Administration, Faculty of Management and Economics, Semnan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Semnan, Iran
5 Professor, Department of Energy Systems Engineering, Faculty of Energy Engineering, Sharif University of Technology, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Given the increasing challenges in ensuring a sustainable energy supply and the widespread imbalances across energy carriers such as electricity and gas, the need to reconsider the current energy governance system has become more critical than ever. The purpose of this study is to design and validate an operational energy governance model based on a sustainable development approach in Iran. Using the Fuzzy Delphi method across three consecutive rounds, involving 23 experts, the study identified and validated the key dimensions and components of operational energy governance. The final model was developed around three main dimensions—actors, level of action, and supply chain—comprising 23 validated components. The most agreed-upon components include stakeholder participation, conflict of interest management, supply chain performance monitoring and evaluation, institutional capacity, and process transparency. This model, as a localized and operational framework, can serve as a foundation for institutional reforms and for improving the implementation of energy policies in Iran.
- Ashraf, M., & Bocca, R. (2023). Fostering Effective Energy Transition. Online: World Economic Forum.
- Bastian, H., Arriagada, P., & Roser, M. (2023). State Capacity. Online: OurWorldInData.
- Ciarreta, A., & Ahmadov, E. (2019). Sustainability on Energy Governance: Recent Trends of the Electricity Sector in Azerbaijan. Economics World, 6(2), 75-95. https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&hl=en&user=aGlzqvgAAAAJ&citation_for_view=aGlzqvgAAAAJ:UeHWp8X0CEIC
- Dubash, N. k. (2011). Mapping Global Energy Governance. Global Policy, Volume 6-18. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1758-5899.2011.00119.x
- Farazmand, A. (2012). Sound Governance: Engaging Citizens through Collaborative Organizations. Public Organization Rev 12, 223–241. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11115-012-0186-7
- Filgueiras, F., Palotti, P. & Testa, G. (2023). Complexing Governance Styles: Connecting Politics and Policy in Governance Theories. SAGE Open, 13(1):215824402311585. https://doi.org/10.1177/21582440231158521
- Florini, A. (2011). The International Energy Agency in Global Energy Governance. Global Policy, Volume 40-50. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1758-5899.2011.00120.x
- Fraune, C. (2022). Energy Democracy and Participation in Energy Transitions. In Handbook of Energy Governance in Europe (pp. 49-66). Switzerland: Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2022.
- Goldthau, A. (2013). the Handbook of Global Energy Policy. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.
- Goldthau, A. & Witte, J. M. (2011). Assessing OPEC’s Performance in Global Energy. Global Policy, Volume 2, 31-39. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1758-5899.2011.00122.x
- Gomez-Valenzuela, V., Harro, V. V., Ramirez, K & Bonilla-Duarte, S. (2023). Understanding Governance in the Jaragua-Bahoruco-Enriquillo Biosphere Reserve: An Empirical Approach. Tropical Conservation Science, 16(1). https://doi.org/10.1177/19400829231218653
- Haapasalo, H., Ingalsuo, K.& Lenkkeri, T. (2006). Linking strategy into operational management: A survey of BSC implementation in Finnish energy sector, Benchmarking, 13 (6), 701-717. https://doi.org/10.1108/14635770610709068
- Habibi, A., Firouzi Jahantigh, F. & Sarafrazi, A. (2015). Fuzzy Delphi Technique for Forecasting and Screening Items. Asian Journal of Research in Business Economics and Management, 5(2), 130-143. https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&hl=en&user=BMY1QMkAAAAJ&citation_for_view=BMY1QMkAAAAJ:7PzlFSSx8tAC
- Hashemizadeh, A., Ju, Y., & Abadi, F. Z. B. (2024). Policy design for renewable energy development based on government support: A system dynamics model. Applied Energy, 376, 124331. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0306261924017148?via%3Dihub
- Heinrich, C. J., Hill, C. J., & Lynn Jr, L. E. (2004). Governance as an organizing theme for empirical research. The art of governance: Analyzing management and administration, 3-19. https://scholar.google.com/citations?view_op=view_citation&hl=en&user=F2n5LJoAAAAJ&citation_for_view=F2n5LJoAAAAJ:W7OEmFMy1HYC
- Hufty, M. (2011). Governance: Exploring four approaches and their relevance to research. Research for sustainable development: Foundations, experiences, and perspectives, 165-186. https://ssrn.com/abstract=2019013
- IEA. (2020). World Energy Outlook. Online: International Energy Agency.
- Knodt, M., & Kemmerzell, J. (2022). Handbook of Energy Governance in Europe. UK: Sprringer.
- Kuo, Y. F., & Chen, P. C. (2008). Constructing a performance appraisal system for R&D personnel using fuzzy delphi method. Omega, 36(4), 559-570.
- Lockwood, M. (2010). Good governance for terrestrial protected areas: A framework, principles and performance outcomes. environmental management, 91(3), 754-766. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2009.10.005
- Loureiro, C. V., Gorayeb, A., & Brannstrom, C. (2017). ANÁLISE COMPARATIVA DE POLÍTICAS DE IMPLANTAÇÃO e RESULTADOS SOCIAIS DA ENERGIA EÓLICA NO BRASIL e NOS ESTADOS UNIDOS. Deleted Journal, 40, 231. https://doi.org/10.5380/raega.v40i0.45344
- Hill, M., Hupe P. (2023). Implementing Public Policy_ Governance in Theory and in Practice (SAGE Politics Texts series)
- Μichalena, E., & Hills, J. M. (2012). Renewable energy issues and implementation of European energy policy: The missing generation? Energy Policy, 45, 201–216. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2012.02.021
- Mkhize, N., & Nel-Sanders, D. (2023). An analysis of Energy Policy Implementation in South Africa: A Case Study of the Gas- to-Power Programme. African Journal of Business and Economic Research, 18(1), 273–290. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/377224426_An_analysis_of_Energy_Policy_Implementation_in_South_Africa_A_Case_Study_of_the_Gas-to-Power_Programme
- Renn, O., & Schweizer, P. (2019). Inclusive governance for energy policy making: Conceptual foundations, applications, and lessons learned. The Role of Public Participation in Energy Transitions, 39-79. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-819515-4.00003-9
- Rhodes, R. W. (1996). The new governance: governing without government. Political studies. 44(4), 652-667. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9248.1996.tb01747.x
- Sahamies, K., Haveri, A. & Anttiroiko, A. (2022). Local Governance Platforms: Roles and Relations of City Governments, Citizens, and Businesses. Administration & Society, 54(9), 1710-1735. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00953997211072531
- Sandu, S., Yang, M., Shi, X., & Chi, Y. (2020). A governance perspective on electricity industry development: The case of Papua New Guinea. Energy Policy, 141(February) , 111464. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2020.111464
- Setyadiharja, R., Kurniasih, D., Nursnaeny, P. S. & Nengsih, N. S. (2017). Good Governance vs Sound Governance: A Comparative Theoretical Analysis. International Conference on Democracy, Accountability and Governance (ICODAG 2017), 92-101, Atlantis Press. https://www.atlantis-press.com/proceedings/icodag-17/25886149
- Sohre, A., & Schubert, I. (2022). The how and what of bottom-up governance to change household energy consumption behaviour. Energy Research & Social Science, 1-14. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2022.102570
- UNDP. (2022). Human Development Report. Online: United Nations Development Programme.
- WorldBank. (2015). Transparency and Social Accountability in the Egyptian Power Sector. Online: World Bank.
- WorldBank. (2022). World Bank Report. Online: World Bank.
- World Energy Trilemma Report. (2024). World Energy Council.
- Zadeh, L. A. (1965). Fuzzy sets. Information and Control. Information sciences, 8(3), 338-353https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-symbolic-logic/article/abs/l-a-zadeh-fuzzy-sets-information-and-control-vol-8-1965-pp-338353-l-a-zadeh-similarity-relations-and-fuzzy-orderings-information-sciences-vol-3-1971-pp-177200/3A80F34917B4A88DD12299044FD1E47E
- Ahadzadeh, A., Sayyad Shirkosh, S. & jamshidi Evanaki, M. (2021). Identify the factors affecting the implementation of public policies in the Ministry of Energy. Iranian Journal of Public Policy, 7(1), 79-96. https://jppolicy.ut.ac.ir/article_81989.html?lang=en[In Persian]
- Asadi, M., Hadi Peykani, M. & Rashidpur, A. (2018). Presentation of an Effective Public Policy Implementation Model in the Ministry of Economic Affairs (Case Study: Islamic Republic of Iran Customs Administration). Journal of Public Administration, 9(4), 591-614. https://jipa.ut.ac.ir/article_65419.html?lang=en[In Persian]
- Eshtarian, K., et al. (2017). Implementation Studies: Challenges of Public Policy Implementation in Iran. Tehran: Siasat-Gozar Publications. [In Persian]
- Akbari, M., Souhankar, A. & Heidari, H. (2021). The Roadmap to Establish the Ministry of Energy in Iran. Rahyaft, 31(2), 87-104. https://rahyaft.nrisp.ac.ir/article_13906.html?lang=en[In Persian]
- Bohloli, H. (2019). Relationship Between Public Sphere and the Reduction of Corruption: A Public Policy Approach. Iranian Journal of Public Policy, 4(4), 225-250. https://doi.org/10.22059/ppolicy.2019.69851[In Persian]
- Pasandideh, A. & Heidari, G. (2024). Paradigm Analysis of Renewable Energy Governance and Policymaking In Iran. Journal of Renewable and New Energy, 11(1), 125-138. https://doi.org/10.22034/jrenew.2024.187737[In Persian]
- Pour-Ezzat, A. (2019). Foundations of Public Administration. Tehran: SAMT. [In Persian]
- Hajimirzaei, Seyed Mohammad Ali, Behrouzi‑far, Morteza, Bahadri, Shirko, & Malek Hosseini, Afsaneh. (2022). Evaluation of Approved Policies in the Energy Sector and Proposal of Policy Recommendations to Improve Energy Governance in Iran. Quarterly Journal of Energy Economics, 20(80), 269–305. https://iiesj.ir/article-1-1617-fa.html[In Persian]
- Denhardt, R. B. (2016). Theories of Public Organization. Tehran: Safar.
- Rangriz, H. & Mozni, B. (2017). Identification and Prioritization of Barriers to the Implementation of Public Policies in Governmental Organizations Using Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Models. Journal of Policy Making in Management, 8(4). https://civilica.com/doc/1794408[In Persian]
- Zali, S., Atarodi, M. & Danaeefard, H. (2018). The Scrutiny of Barriers Pattern in Implementation of Meta-policies on Fighting Against Drugs in Iran. Strategy, 27(3), 185-215. https://rahbord.csr.ir/article_117686.html?lang=en
- Shahbazi, K., Hekmati Farid, S. & Rezaei, H. (2016). The Effect of Government Size and Good Governance on Energy Consumption Intensity: A Case Study of OPEC Countries. Applied Theories of Economics, 2(4), 23-48. https://ecoj.tabrizu.ac.ir/article_4751.html?lang=en[In Persian]
- Saberi,A., Zafarian, H. (2023a). Strategic Issues of the Energy Sector in the Seventh Development Plan (1): Natural Gas Storage. Tehran: Majlis Research Center. https://sid.ir/paper/1065748/fa[In Persian]
- Saberi, A., Zafarian,H. (2023b). Natural Gas Imbalance in the Country (2): Framework of Proposed Solutions. Monthly Journal of Expert Reports, Majlis Research Center of the Islamic Republic of Iran, 31(10), 1–26. https://rc.majlis.ir/fa/report/show/1793152[In Persian]
- Saberi, A., Zafarian, H. (2023c). Natural Gas Imbalance in the Country (1): An Overview of the Imbalance. Majlis Research Center. [In Persian]
- Salehi Shahrabi, N., Pourezzat, A. A., Vahid Mahmodi, V. & Ghasemi, M. (2019). Reviewing Electricity Policies by Green Management Approach (Comparison of Denmark and Germany with Iran). Public Management Researches, 12(43), 85-109. https://jmr.usb.ac.ir/article_4744.html?lang=en[In Persian]
- Talebipour Farsangi, S., Ziaeddini, M. & Rajabi Behjat, A. (2022). A Model for Enhancing the Implementation Capacity of Renewable Energy Policies in Iran’s 2025 Vision Document (Case Study: Electricity Generation and Renewable Energy Sector). Management and Sustainable Development Studies, 2(3).https://sanad.iau.ir/en/Journal/msds/Article/695376?jid=695376[In Persian]
- Taherpour Kalantari, H. & Memarzadeh Tehran, G. (2008). Factors Affecting the Successful Implementation of Tax Policies Approved by the Parliament. Economic Research Journal, No. 4, 45–68. https://sid.ir/paper/66991/en[In Persian]
- Zafarian, H., Nourbakhsh, A., Soleimanpour, J., Safari, A. & Akbari, M. (2022). Re-Architecting the Country’s Energy Trade: Iran’s New Positioning in the International Economy and Politics. Tehran: Amirkabir Policy-Making Think Tank Research Report. https://iranthinktanks.com/open-architecture-of-the-countrys-energy-trade/[In Persian]
- Fartash, K., Khayyatian Yazdi, M. S. & Ghorbani, A. (2020). The role of actors in the solar energy governance in Iran: A critical study. Iranian Journal of Public Policy, 6(2), 155-177. https://doi.org/10.22059/jppolicy.2020.77618[In Persian]
- Ghalaychi, M., Rahnavard, F. & Mortazavi, M. (2022). Identifying the Criteria for Successful Implementation of Industrial Property Policy. Journal of Iranian Public Administration Studies, 5(2), 139-178. https://jipas.ir/article_151747_en.html[In Persian]
- Kasiri, M., Ranjbar, P. & Pilehforoush, M. (2018). On the Establishment of the Ministry of Energy: Requirements for the Formation of the Ministry of Energy. Tehran: Majlis Research Center, Office of Energy, Industry, and Mining Studies, Serial No. 15921. https://rc.majlis.ir/fa/report/show/1064278[In Persian]
- Kohan Houshnejad, R. (2019). Good Governance in the Oil and Gas Industry: A Comparison of Iran and Norway. Tehran: Iran Energy and Resources Governance Think Tank. https://iranergi.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/13.pdf[In Persian]
- Quivy, R., & Van campenhoudt, L. (2022). Research Methods in Social Sciences (A. N. Gahar, Trans.). Totia Publications. [In Persian]
- Mohammadi, N. & Danaeefard, H. (2019). A Participatory Governance Model for Renewable Energy Development in Iran: An Institutional Approach. Energy Policy and Planning Research Quarterly, (61) 5, 16–35. https://epprjournal.ir/article-1-552-en.html[In Persian]
- Marzban, E., Mohammadi, M. & Pourezzat, A. (2018). Governance in the Field of Energy Distribution in Iran: Foresighting and Developing Policy Options. Iranian Journal of Public Policy, 4(3), 9-26. https://jppolicy.ut.ac.ir/m/article_68239.html?lang=en[In Persian]
- Mazkouri, A., memarzadeh Tehran, G., Mousakhani, M., Moghimi, Z. & Saboohi, Y. (2024). Rethinking Laws and Institutions in Operational Energy Governance in Iran: From Policies to Their Implementation on the Path to Sustainable Development. Journal of Management and Development Processes, 38(2), 61–94. https://jmdp.ir/article-1-4836-fa.html[In Persian]
- Mazkouri, A., memarzadeh Tehran, G., Mousakhani, M., Moghimi, Z. & Saboohi, Y. (2025). A Framework for an Operational Energy Governance Model in Iran from a Sustainable Development Perspective: A Systematic Review. Governance and Development Journal, 5(3), 31-66. https://www.jipaaa.ir/article_230823_en.html[In Persian]